Latest News

Chandarana Worker Loses Appeal After Crucial Court Record Goes Missing

case law

A five-year employment battle ended without a ruling on alleged theft, unfair dismissal or compensation. The appellate court instead found one crucial document missing.

A former Chandarana Food Plus cashier has lost his appeal after a crucial court document disappeared.

The Employment and Labour Relations Court dismissed Marango Peter Siekisa’s appeal on procedural grounds.

Justice Monica Mbaru delivered the judgement in Nairobi on September 25, 2026.

Yet the ruling did not determine whether Chandarana lawfully dismissed Siekisa over alleged misconduct.

Instead, the court found the appeal lacked an essential part of its record.

That missing document was Chandarana’s Response and Counterclaim from the original proceedings.

Justice Mbaru described the missing pleading as a “vital and necessary record” for determining the appeal.

The omission ultimately proved fatal, ending Siekisa’s challenge without a merits-based ruling.

The Arrest

Siekisa joined Chandarana Food Plus as a cashier on March 10, 2015.

He was stationed at the supermarket’s Yaya branch in Nairobi.

His employment changed dramatically on April 25, 2016, according to the judgement.

That day, assistant manager Krishna allegedly arrived at his workstation with police officers.

The officers arrested Siekisa and took him to Kilimani Police Station.

Police also obtained his M-Pesa details during the investigation, according to his account.

Siekisa maintained that police never charged him with any criminal offence.

He further said the alleged theft remained unresolved for approximately eight months.

Chandarana eventually issued him with a summary dismissal letter on November 19, 2016.

The dismissal allegedly concerned a criminal offence arising from the disputed incident.

Siekisa insisted that no disciplinary hearing preceded his dismissal.

That omission became central to his later challenge against the supermarket.

Dismissal Fight

Siekisa appealed internally against his dismissal on December 1, 2016.

He was subsequently invited to an appeal hearing scheduled for December 2.

His internal appeal was ultimately unsuccessful, according to the judgement.

He then pursued the dispute before the Employment and Labour Relations Court.

Siekisa sought unpaid wages, leave pay, notice pay and compensation for unfair termination.

His wage claim totalled KSh338,884 for the disputed employment period.

He separately sought KSh376,536 as compensation equivalent to 12 months’ salary.

He also claimed KSh21,964 for accrued leave and KSh31,378 as notice pay.

His case rested heavily on the alleged absence of substantive and procedural justification.

He argued that Chandarana had failed to prove gross misconduct justifying summary dismissal.

He also argued that no criminal offence had been established against him.

Those arguments eventually reached the appellate court after the magistrate rejected his claim.

The magistrate had found that due process justified the summary dismissal, the judgement records.

Siekisa then asked the appellate, in this case the ELRC court, to overturn that decision.

But the appeal encountered a problem before those substantive questions could be examined.

Missing File

Justice Mbarũ began by examining the Record of Appeal placed before the court.

The judge found that Chandarana’s Response and Counterclaim was absent from that record.

The appellant’s Reply referred to the missing pleading, but the pleading itself was unavailable.

The Record’s index also failed to identify the respondent’s Response and Counterclaim.

Even a Supplementary Record of Appeal failed to correct the omission.

Chandarana itself later filed submissions without attaching the missing response and counterclaim.

For the appellate court, that was more than a technical paperwork problem.

The missing document contained the respondent’s position in the original employment dispute.

Without it, the judge said the respondent’s case could not receive proper context.

The court therefore found the appeal contrary to mandatory procedural requirements.

Justice Mbarũ cited Section 17 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act.

The judge also cited Rules 12, 15, 16 and 18 governing appellate procedure.

The court concluded that the appeal had “no foundation” because that record remained incomplete.

That conclusion effectively closed the door on Siekisa’s substantive arguments.

Merits Untouched

The judgement leaves one important fact unmistakably clear about the dispute.

The appellate court never decided whether Siekisa committed the alleged theft.

It also never determined whether Chandarana proved gross misconduct against its former cashier.

Nor did Justice Mbarũ determine whether Siekisa received adequate disciplinary process before dismissal.

The court similarly did not decide whether Siekisa deserved the monetary claims he had presented.

Those questions remained untouched because the appellate record was incomplete.

The court held that addressing the appeal without the missing material would not foster justice.

It therefore declared the omission fatal and dismissed the appeal.

Importantly, the court made no order requiring either party to pay costs.

The judgement thus resolves the appeal through procedure rather than the disputed workplace allegations.

For Siekisa, that means his challenge ended without the merits being reconsidered.

READ ALSO: Court Says JOOUST Rightly Fired KSh610,000-a-Month HR Manager

For Chandarana, the appellate dismissal leaves the earlier judgement standing.

The case offers a sharp reminder about the unforgiving nature of appellate procedure.

A party may have substantive arguments, but those arguments require a complete record.

Here, one missing pleading became more consequential than the alleged workplace misconduct.

The dispute began with an arrest, MPesa records and an alleged theft.

It ended instead with a missing document and a dismissed appeal.

PAY ATTENTION: Reach us at info@gotta.news.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Most Popular

To Top
error: Content is protected !!