A Migori businessman faces an escalating tax demand after the Tribunal declined jurisdiction. His challenge over KRA’s refusal to admit a late objection remains unresolved, leaving judicial review as his potential remedy.
The Tax Appeals Tribunal has struck out an appeal by a Migori businessman challenging KRA’s KSh 80.4 million tax demand.
The Tribunal ruled that it lacked jurisdiction because the taxpayer challenged a decision outside its statutory appellate mandate.
At the heart of the dispute was whether KRA could refuse a late objection. The businessman wanted the Tribunal to examine that refusal and reopen the tax dispute.
The case involved Noor Hassan Abdullahi, trading as Victoria Enterprises, a wholesale and retail business.
His enterprise operates in Kehancha Market, Migori County, dealing mainly in maize flour.
The November 6, 2026 judgement leaves his substantive challenge to KRA’s assessment unresolved.
It also highlights the costly consequences of procedural missteps in Kenya’s tax dispute system.
KSh100 Million Battle
The dispute began when KRA investigated Abdullahi’s tax affairs between 2018 and 2022. On December 7, 2023, the Commissioner issued revised findings and demanded KSh 51.25 million.
The assessment comprised KSh 1.91 million in Income Tax and KSh 49.35 million in VAT. Investigators relied on bank deposits amounting to KSh 735,164,836, which they treated as business income.
KRA also backdated his VAT registration to December 2018. Additionally, investigators adopted a 5.14 per cent gross profit margin from comparable businesses.
They also calculated sales ratios using purchases declared by the businessman’s principal suppliers. Abdullahi would later challenge these calculations as arbitrary and unsupported by his records.
His then tax agent, Julie Ward & Company, requested additional time on January 5, 2024. The agent explained that supporting documents were still being compiled for the objection.
KRA subsequently demanded supporting documentation by January 19, 2024. However, the taxpayer’s representatives reiterated their request for thirty additional days.
On January 25, 2024, the Commissioner confirmed the assessments. It declared that the taxpayer had failed to validate his objection within fourteen days.
KRA stated that, “in the absence of a valid objection,” it rejected the objection. It consequently confirmed the principal tax liability, together with applicable penalties and interest.
First Defeat
Abdullahi subsequently challenged the decision before the Tribunal in Appeal E1441 of 2024. On September 19, 2025, the Tribunal dismissed his appeal.
It found that he had failed to validate his objection as required by law. Consequently, there was no appealable objection decision before the Tribunal.
The Tribunal upheld KRA’s January 25, 2024 decision and awarded no costs. The businessman’s procedural difficulties, however, did not end with that judgement.
On October 23, 2025, KRA issued another demand totalling KSh 80,431,798.99. The amount included KSh 51.20 million principal tax and KSh 5.04 million penalties.
Accumulated interest accounted for another KSh 24.19 million. The escalating liability became a central concern in Abdullahi’s subsequent challenge.
On January 28, 2026, he returned to KRA through Westminster Consulting. He sought permission to lodge a late objection under Section 51 of the Tax Procedures Act.
Abdullahi attributed the delay to professional advice and procedural misdirection. He maintained that he had pursued the dispute before the Tribunal mistakenly.
However, KRA rejected his application on February 4, 2026. The Commissioner argued that the earlier confirmation had already concluded the objection process.
Wrong Forum
Abdullahi accused KRA of mechanically exercising its discretion without considering his explanation. He argued that his continuous pursuit of the dispute demonstrated diligence rather than abandonment.
He relied on Section 51(7), which permits extensions where reasonable cause explains delayed objections. The provision also requires that taxpayers must not have unreasonably delayed lodging their objections.
His lawyers argued that the refusal violated Article 47 of the Constitution. They maintained that KRA denied him fair administrative action and an opportunity to challenge the assessment.
Beyond procedure, Abdullahi disputed the substance of KRA’s tax calculations. He questioned the adopted profit margin and the reconstruction of his business income.
He also maintained that investigators disregarded documented input VAT and legitimate business expenses. His VAT certificate, he argued, recognised May 18, 2023 as registration’s effective date.
KRA maintained that the taxpayer had exhausted the statutory objection process. It also argued that the February decision was not appealable before the Tribunal.
The panel, chaired by Robert M. Mutuma, identified one decisive question. It had to determine whether it possessed jurisdiction to hear the appeal.
The Tribunal distinguished an objection decision from a refusal to extend objection deadlines. Under Section 51(8), an objection decision allows or disallows a valid objection.
Section 51(10) additionally requires findings on material facts and reasons. KRA’s February 4 letter neither determined an objection nor examined the underlying assessments.
Judicial Review
The Tribunal relied heavily on the High Court decision in Commissioner of Investigations and Enforcement v Maulik Vyas. The 2022 decision established that refusing a late objection attracts judicial review, not an appeal.
It also cited Agigu Company Limited v Commissioner of Domestic Taxes (2025). That decision similarly recognised the Tribunal’s lack of jurisdiction over Section 51(7) discretion.
The panel distinguished Fazal Dharamshi and Company Limited v KRA (2026). That dispute concerned customs legislation expressly providing appeals against late-review decisions.
Section 230(1) of the East African Community Customs Management Act provides that appeal mechanism. The Tax Procedures Act contains no equivalent provision for Section 51(7) refusals.
The Tribunal also invoked the Court of Appeal’s decision in Panalpina Airflo Limited v Commissioner of Domestic Taxes (2026). It distinguished statutory appeals from judicial review of administrative conduct.
The panel concluded that Abdullahi’s grievances concerned administrative legality and procedural fairness. Such complaints belonged before the High Court rather than the Tribunal.
It consequently declared KRA’s February 4 decision non-appealable. The Tribunal struck out the appeal and ordered each party to bear its own costs.
READ ALSO: I&M Bank Wins KSh713 Million Tax Battle as Tribunal Faults KRA’s Bad Debt Claim
Importantly, the judgement did not establish that KRA’s tax calculations were correct. Neither did it determine whether the backdated VAT registration was lawful.
The businessman’s objections concerning input VAT, expenses, and reconstructed income remain untested. The KSh 80.4 million demand was not set aside by this judgement.
For Abdullahi, judicial review now offers a potential avenue for challenging KRA’s refusal. His battle with the taxman remains unresolved, despite two unsuccessful Tribunal proceedings.
PAY ATTENTION: Reach us at info@gotta.news.