Latest News

Naipa Supermarkets Loses Bid to Freeze New KCC Assets Over KSh420 Million Claim

Posted on

Naipa Supermarkets feared Government-backed restructuring could leave it chasing KSh419.7 million in damages. But the High Court found no evidence of impending asset sales, suspicious transfers, or insolvency.

New Kenya Co-operative Creameries (New KCC) has escaped an attempted asset freeze over a disputed KSh419.7 million claim.

The High Court in Lodwar dismissed a supermarket’s application seeking sweeping restrictions against the dairy processor.

Naipa Supermarkets Limited feared Government-backed restructuring could undermine its ability to recover damages.

It wanted the company restrained from selling, transferring, leasing, or charging its assets.

The supermarket also sought restrictions on bank accounts and KSh420 million security.

However, Justice Patrick Otieno found insufficient evidence supporting those extraordinary measures.

In a ruling delivered on November 13, 2026, the judge rejected every substantive prayer.

He warned that granting the proposed orders would effectively cripple New KCC’s commercial operations.

The Dispute

The dispute originated from a distribution agreement signed on January 1, 2022. The parties subsequently executed an addendum on January 1, 2024.

Naipa maintained that the agreement granted exclusive distribution rights within Lodwar. It accused New KCC of breaching the arrangement by appointing another distributor.

The supermarket specifically challenged the appointment of Darusalam General Stores and Contractors Limited.

New KCC rejected the allegations, arguing that exclusivity was never expressly guaranteed.

It maintained that the agreement permitted additional distributors within the market.

The dairy processor also accused Naipa of progressively reducing purchases before abandoning collections.

It further claimed the supermarket owed KSh4,989,519.89 by January 10, 2025.

The dispute eventually moved to arbitration following court directions issued December 1, 2025.

Naipa subsequently lodged a claim worth KSh419,710,558 before the Arbitral Tribunal.

New KCC disputed liability and quantum, subsequently filing its defence and counterclaim.

The arbitration hearing was scheduled for November 5 and 18, 2026. Neither company’s substantive claims had been determined when the High Court considered Naipa’s application.

Restructuring Fears

The supermarket’s fears intensified following government pronouncements during an agricultural transformation summit.

The Agriculture and Food Systems Transformation Summit ran from October 7 to 9. It was held at Nairobi’s Jamhuri Park ASK Showground.

Among the announced proposals was an anticipated KSh8 billion government intervention.

The money was intended to address New KCC’s outstanding debts and liabilities.

Other measures included modernising factories and reorganising the company’s financial operations.

The proposed reforms also included mandatory biweekly payments to dairy farmers.

Naipa feared restructuring could facilitate transfers of factories and other valuable assets.

Managing Director Anthony Munene Kibetu argued that such transactions threatened eventual recovery.

He wanted New KCC ordered to provide KSh420 million in security within 14 days.

The proposed security would comprise an irrevocable bank guarantee or joint escrow deposit.

Naipa argued that the amount represented only 5.25 per cent of the government’s proposed intervention.

It maintained that such security would protect its interests without disrupting operations.

New KCC dismissed these concerns as speculative and unsupported by concrete evidence.

It insisted that restructuring targeted operational efficiency rather than defeating outstanding claims.

No Evidence

Justice Otieno agreed that courts possess protective powers during arbitration proceedings. Section 7 of the Arbitration Act permits interim measures before or during arbitration.

However, that jurisdiction does not automatically justify freezing a respondent’s assets.

The judge relied on the Court of Appeal’s decision in Safaricom v Ocean View Beach Hotel [2010].

The decision requires courts to examine whether arbitration’s subject matter faces genuine danger.

Judges must also assess whether proposed protection remains appropriate and proportionate.

Justice Otieno found that Naipa had failed to establish an identifiable threat.

It had not produced agreements, proposed leases, or documents showing imminent asset transfers.

Neither had it identified suspicious withdrawals from particular bank accounts.

The judge observed that restructuring could involve ownership changes or operational reorganisation.

However, announcing such a programme does not establish an intention to defeat creditors.

He further distinguished the arbitration’s monetary claim from New KCC’s general commercial assets.

The factories, machinery, vehicles, and bank accounts were not the dispute’s subject matter.

Importantly, the judge did not rule out protecting general assets during arbitration.

He explained that sufficient evidence could justify such intervention where enforcement faces genuine danger.

But Naipa had demonstrated neither insolvency nor deliberate asset dissipation. Its claim remained monetary, and any established losses could be assessed financially.

Crippling Orders

The judge was particularly troubled by the sweeping nature of Naipa’s proposed restrictions.

The supermarket wanted New KCC barred from virtually every significant asset transaction.

It also sought restrictions to “immobilise and cripple the respondent”, affecting access to the company’s banking facilities.

Justice Otieno warned that granting those orders would effectively

New KCC had explained that uninterrupted banking access supported milk procurement and processing.

Its operations also depended on paying farmers, employees, suppliers, and transporters. The company further warned that dairy products were highly perishable.

The judge considered these concerns legitimate and rejected disproportionate commercial restrictions.

He found that the balance of convenience favoured continued business operations.

Naipa also failed to satisfy Order 39’s requirements for attachment before judgement. The law requires evidence of impending disposal intended to frustrate execution.

Applicants must additionally identify properties and provide their estimated values.

The supermarket supplied neither specific property descriptions nor corresponding valuations.

Consequently, the court rejected both security and attachment before judgement.

Another complication involved the National Treasury and relevant government institutions.

The Privatisation Authority had not been joined to the proceedings.

Justice Otieno observed that restraining restructuring could interfere with its statutory mandate.

He found that imposing such restrictions without hearing the Authority would undermine procedural fairness.

READ ALSO: Court Orders Sony Sugar to Pay Farmer KSh27 Million After Botched Cane Harvest

Ultimately, the judge dismissed Naipa’s October 12, 2026 application. The costs were ordered to remain costs in the cause.

The decision does not extinguish Naipa’s KSh419.7 million arbitration claim. Neither does it resolve New KCC’s counterclaim or determine contractual liability.

Those questions remain before the Arbitral Tribunal. For now, New KCC can pursue restructuring without the sweeping restrictions sought.

The ruling nevertheless draws an important distinction between creditor protection and commercial paralysis.

Courts require concrete evidence before freezing assets over unresolved monetary claims.

PAY ATTENTION: Reach us at info@gotta.news.

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.

Most Popular

Exit mobile version