The manufacturer, whose paper and stationery products have served Kenyan schools and businesses since 1972, won major relief after the Tribunal exposed flaws in KRA’s tax calculations. However, it upheld KSh100.86 million in insurance compensation as taxable income.
The Tax Appeals Tribunal has overturned a KSh57.4 million PAYE assessment against stationery manufacturer Kartasi Products Limited.
The decision exposed serious weaknesses in the Kenya Revenue Authority’s investigation and accounting methodology.
The Tribunal also overturned nearly KSh940 million in disputed purchases disallowances, granting the company substantial tax relief.
However, Kartasi suffered a significant setback over KSh100.86 million received from insurers after devastating inventory losses.
In a judgement delivered on November 6, 2026, the Tribunal partly allowed Kartasi’s appeal against KRA.
The dispute covered corporation tax, PAYE, withholding tax, VAT, and stamp duty.
Kartasi traces its roots to 1972, when it began manufacturing exercise books in Kenya.
Over the decades, it expanded into a broad range of school and office stationery products.
Its portfolio includes notebooks, accounting books, files, tapes, labels, and other paper-based products.
The company also promotes sugarcane-based paper as part of its environmental manufacturing approach.
The Tax Dispute
Kartasi acquired Kartasi Industries Limited’s business and assets in 2022, including its Enterprise Road premises.
KRA notified the company of an impending tax audit on August 27, 2024.
The investigation covered corporation tax, PAYE, withholding tax, VAT and stamp duty.
After issuing preliminary findings, KRA raised additional assessments on December 4, 2025.
The authority demanded KSh458.63 million in principal taxes, before penalties and interest.
The total demand consequently reached KSh576.48 million.
Kartasi objected on January 2, 2026, challenging the calculations and supporting evidence.
KRA partially allowed the objection but confirmed KSh509.28 million on February 27.
The company subsequently appealed to the Tribunal, challenging several components of the assessment.
PAYE Controversy
Kartasi secured its biggest victory against KRA’s KSh57.4 million PAYE assessment.
Investigators compared money available to the company against payments recorded during three financial years.
They treated unexplained differences as fringe benefits and calculated additional employment taxes.
The discrepancies exceeded KSh408.6 million in 2022 and KSh352.45 million in 2023.
For 2024, investigators identified a further variance of KSh796.91 million.
Applying different fringe benefit rates and a 30 per cent tax rate produced the disputed assessment.
Kartasi argued that accounting discrepancies alone could not establish taxable employee benefits.
The Tribunal agreed, finding that KRA had identified neither qualifying loans nor their supposed beneficiaries.
Section 12B of the Income Tax Act concerns low-interest loans provided by employers.
Such loans must involve identifiable employees, directors, or their relatives receiving employment-related benefits.
KRA had not established that any such loans existed.
The Tribunal delivered a firm finding on the authority’s approach.
“An unexplained variance in a funds test, whatever its size, is not a loan or an emolument,” it declared.
It added that PAYE must arise from employment income or benefits recognised under legislation.
The authority therefore could not convert unexplained financial differences into taxable employee benefits.
The Tribunal consequently overturned the entire KSh57,406,381 assessment, including associated penalties and interest.
Purchases Dispute
The Tribunal also dismantled KRA’s methodology for calculating Kartasi’s purchases and business expenses.
Investigators had compared VAT purchases against figures representing cost of goods sold.
However, the Tribunal found that purchases and cost of goods sold are different accounting measures.
Cost of goods sold incorporates opening inventory, purchases, and closing inventory adjustments.
Kartasi argued that KRA had ignored substantial inventory movements when calculating its purchases.
Its closing inventory stood at KSh1.05 billion in December 2022.
That figure declined to approximately KSh534.41 million by December 2023.
After applying the correct accounting formula, the Tribunal established purchases exceeding KSh1.4 billion in 2022.
The corresponding figure for 2023 was approximately KSh1.32 billion.
The Tribunal overturned KSh379.2 million in disallowed purchases for 2022.
It also overturned another KSh560.88 million disallowance relating to 2023.
However, Kartasi failed to substantiate every expenditure claimed during the disputed periods.
The Tribunal retained KSh5,959 in unsupported 2022 purchases and KSh70.76 million for 2023.
The latter included KSh82.46 million in labour costs lacking adequate supporting documentation.
It also involved unexplained discrepancies in electricity and water expenses.
The Tribunal stressed that company-prepared reconciliations must connect individual entries to verifiable records.
It nevertheless rejected KRA’s broader approach, which overlooked audited inventory figures.
Insurance Setback
Kartasi lost its argument concerning KSh100,862,906.51 received from insurers during 2024.
The payment followed floods that destroyed substantial quantities of the company’s trading inventory.
The damaged stock included newsprint, woodfree paper, manufacturing materials, and finished stationery.
Kartasi maintained that the compensation represented indemnification rather than ordinary business income.
The Tribunal disagreed, distinguishing trading inventory from destroyed capital assets.
It held that compensation generally assumes the tax character of whatever it replaces.
“The character of a compensation receipt follows the character of what it replaces,” the Tribunal observed.
Inventory forms part of circulating business capital, unlike buildings and other fixed assets.
The company had also charged approximately KSh100.55 million in destroyed stock costs against business income.
Excluding the insurance proceeds would therefore preserve a deduction for losses already reimbursed.
The Tribunal consequently upheld the entire KSh100.86 million compensation as taxable business income.
It distinguished an earlier ruling involving compensation for destroyed buildings.
Beyond the major disputes, the Tribunal overturned KRA’s telephone expense disallowances.
Those deductions amounted to KSh16,440 in 2022 and KSh133,518 in 2023.
It also ordered KRA to recompute the KSh3.13 million withholding tax assessment.
The authority must identify qualifying service payments and exclude goods and recoverable third-party expenses.
READ ALSO: I&M Bank Wins KSh713 Million Tax Battle as Tribunal Faults KRA’s Bad Debt Claim
The Tribunal struck out the separate KSh9 million stamp duty appeal for want of jurisdiction.
It held that the Stamp Duty Act directs such appeals to the High Court.
KRA must now issue a revised objection decision within sixty days.
The authority must also credit KSh5 million already paid against Kartasi’s 2024 corporation tax.
Both parties were ordered to bear their respective costs.
The ruling underscores that tax assessments must rest on evidence and statutory authority.
KRA’s investigative powers do not excuse unsupported calculations or arbitrary accounting assumptions.
PAY ATTENTION: Reach us at info@gotta.news.