Latest News

KMFRI’s Former Interns Expose How Directors’ Relatives Landed Jobs

Posted on

Justice Ocharo Kebira has nullified a second recruitment exercise at KMFRI after two former interns challenged alleged backdoor appointments. The petition exposed claims involving relatives of senior officials, irregular interviews and appointments exceeding advertised vacancies.

The Employment and Labour Relations Court in Mombasa has nullified appointments arising from a controversial second recruitment exercise at the Kenya Marine and Fisheries Research Institute (KMFRI).

Justice Ocharo Kebira ruled that the exercise at the state research institute violated constitutional principles governing public appointments, transparency and equal opportunity.

The decision followed a petition by two former interns who questioned how relatives of senior management allegedly secured positions.

John Father Small and Oliver Masawa accused senior officials of facilitating the employment of their sons, daughters and spouses.

In sworn affidavits, the petitioners named several directors and senior officers allegedly connected to successful candidates.

The judge observed that their petition raised questions beyond the disappointment of unsuccessful applicants.

It questioned whether a public institution could advertise vacancies before quietly creating another recruitment route.

“It asks whether a public body that has publicly invited all qualified Kenyans to compete for posts may thereafter, quietly and without notice to the public or to those who answered its call, open a side door,” Justice Kebira observed.

Family Connections

Among those named was Dr Jacob Ochiewo, KMFRI’s Director of Socioeconomics and Senior Research Scientist.

The petitioners also implicated Dr Irene Muthoni Githaiga, Deputy Director of Human Resource and Administration.

Justus Andati, a Senior Technologist and Principal Officer for Laboratory Services, was also mentioned.

Jared Nyaundi, the institute’s Acting Supply Chain Manager and Senior Procurement Officer, faced separate allegations.

Small’s affidavit attributed successful appointments to relatives of several senior officers.

The petitioners presented two tables identifying officials and their alleged family connections to successful candidates.

One table named Ochiewo, Githaiga and Andati, alongside their alleged relatives.

The second identified other senior officers whose relatives allegedly secured positions.

Masawa separately accused Nyaundi of influencing the recruitment process.

He alleged that Nyaundi served on both the shortlisting committee and interview panel.

According to the petitioners, this arrangement created opportunities to manipulate both recruitment stages.

These allegations formed part of the petitioners’ case and were not independent findings of criminal wrongdoing.

120 Appointments

The dispute originated from an advertisement for 71 vacancies across 25 positions.

KMFRI intended to fill the positions on temporary 12-month contracts.

Small had worked in the Corporate Communication and Public Relations Department between January 2025 and January 2026.

Masawa served in the Research Department and laboratories between January 2019 and December 2024.

Both subsequently applied for positions related to their previous assignments.

Small unsuccessfully applied for positions in the department where he had served as an intern.

Masawa sought Laboratory Analyst and Assistant Research Scientist positions.

The petitioners questioned the outcome of interviews conducted in January 2026.

They alleged that Masawa was shortlisted for both positions but never received feedback.

They further challenged a second interview conducted on February 10, 2026.

According to their petition, the second exercise included candidates who had not participated in initial shortlisting.

They also alleged that KMFRI ultimately recruited 120 people against the 71 advertised vacancies.

Small claimed the first 71 successful candidates had formerly worked as casual employees.

He described the advertisement as an attempt to legitimise earlier appointments made through questionable recruitment arrangements.

The petitioners further argued that all candidates attending the second interviews secured appointments.

Unconstitutional Process

Justice Kebira found the second recruitment exercise unconstitutional.

The judge faulted the process initiated through an internal memorandum issued by the Director General.

He declared the February 10 interviews and resulting appointments improper.

The court found violations of constitutional provisions governing equality, fair administrative action and public service values.

These included Articles 10, 27, 47, 73 and 232 of the Constitution.

The judge subsequently issued an order of certiorari quashing the second interview proceedings and resulting appointments.

He specifically nullified appointments communicated through a February 11, 2026 memorandum.

The judge, however, declined to invalidate the initial recruitment of 71 candidates.

He also declined to order an entirely fresh recruitment exercise.

Importantly, the ruling did not automatically establish every allegation of nepotism advanced by the petitioners.

Rather, the court found the second recruitment process constitutionally defective.

KMFRI’s Defence

KMFRI maintained that its recruitment exercise was fair, transparent and competitive.

The institution said it complied with applicable laws and its Human Resource Policies and Procedures Manual.

It further argued that committee members declared actual or potential conflicts of interest.

KMFRI denied considering familial relationships when selecting successful candidates.

It also maintained that the petitioners had failed to prove their allegations concerning relatives.

The institution explained that a nine-member verification committee reviewed applications after the advertisement closed.

Small allegedly failed to meet the shortlisting criteria, while Masawa was unsuccessful on merit.

Regarding the second exercise, KMFRI said its Board of Management directed departments to prioritise certain former casual employees.

These included workers who had missed the January interviews and previously interviewed candidates.

The board also considered staffing requests from understaffed departments, subject to available funding.

Justice Kebira declined to grant the petitioners compensation over alleged psychological torture and failure to receive recruitment feedback.

READ ALSO: George Aladwa: Court Clears EACC to Pursue KSh65 Million Buruburu Land

He similarly dismissed their constitutional access-to-information claim.

The judge held that they had not exhausted procedures provided under the Access to Information Act, 2016.

However, KMFRI remains free to fill genuine vacancies through an open and competitive recruitment exercise.

The court emphasised that the affected candidates could also compete alongside other qualified Kenyans.

“In such a process, the persons whose appointments are quashed, like every other qualified Kenyan, will be free to compete,” Justice Kebira ruled.

PAY ATTENTION: Reach us at info@gotta.news.

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.

Most Popular

Exit mobile version