Latest News

Hasmukh Patel: Mombasa Cement Empire Rocked by Nephew’s Billion-Shilling Forgery Claims

Posted on

The nephew alleges his late father was stripped of billions in Mombasa Cement shares through forged documents and backdated transfers. The High Court struck out his application but left the fraud allegations unresolved.

The multi-billion business empire of the late billionaire Hasmukh Kanji Patel has been dragged into a bitter family dispute over allegations of fraud, forgery and disputed share transfers.

His nephew, Khalid Arvind Kanji Patel, claims his late father lost billions in company shares through fraudulent transactions allegedly orchestrated by family members.

Khalid alleges that his uncle, Hasmukh, acquired his father’s interests in five companies through forged documents and backdated transfers.

The companies include Mombasa Cement Limited, Vishna Holding Limited, Kavee Quarries Limited, Venus Metal Developers Limited and Sunny Construction Company Limited.

However, Justice Jairus Ngaah has struck out Khalid’s proceedings over fundamental procedural defects.

The judge nevertheless observed that the underlying dispute deserved a full trial.

Forged Signatures

Khalid alleges that his late father, Arvind Kanji Premji Patel, never authorised the transfer of his shares.

He claims the documents supporting the transactions, including transfer deeds, company minutes and declarations, carried forged signatures.

According to his affidavit, Arvind held shares in the five companies before his death on May 1, 2013.

Khalid maintains that the disputed transfers were allegedly registered using documents backdated to December 2012.

He argues that his father could not have executed the documents because he was critically ill and receiving treatment in India.

Arvind reportedly suffered from ulcerative colitis and underwent major surgery in Mumbai in September 2012.

He subsequently underwent chemotherapy, according to the affidavit filed in court.

Khalid further alleges that forensic examinations conducted by the Directorate of Criminal Investigations support his forgery claims.

He accuses his elder brother, Suraj Patel, and company directors of facilitating the disputed transactions.

Suraj is a director of the five companies whose shareholding forms the centre of the dispute.

Khalid also alleges that the transactions were registered without proper company approvals or payment of his father’s entitlements.

Billions Disputed

The disputed shareholding forms a substantial part of Khalid’s claim against the companies and their directors.

In his application, he sought restoration of the following shares to his father’s estate:

  • Mombasa Cement Limited: 27,885 shares.
  • Vishna Holding Limited: 13,834 shares.
  • Kavee Quarries Limited: 400 shares.
  • Venus Metal Developers Limited: 98,000 shares.
  • Sunny Construction Company Limited: 12,000 shares.

He relied on the companies’ annual returns filed in 2012 to establish his father’s previous shareholding.

Khalid also claims the estate remains unpaid for credit balances owed by two companies.

He demanded KSh 12,790,354 from Kavee Quarries Limited and KSh 719,624 from Venus Metal Developers Limited.

He sought interest at 14 per cent annually, running from May 22, 2013, until full payment.

The nephew further accused Hasmukh of obtaining a grant of probate on January 29, 2014, using an allegedly forged will.

According to Khalid, Hasmukh had petitioned for probate in September 2013.

He also questioned the timing of the disputed share transfers and their subsequent stamping.

Although allegedly executed in December 2012, the documents were stamped in February 2013.

Khalid argued that the transactions were backdated and failed to comply with applicable legal requirements.

He said he discovered the alleged irregularities in November 2022 after examining company records.

He subsequently reported the matter to Nyali Police Station.

 Court Intervention

Khalid approached the High Court as a personal representative of his father’s estate.

He relied on limited letters of administration ad litem issued by the Mombasa Chief Magistrate’s Court on November 19, 2025.

His application, dated December 9, 2025, sought sweeping orders against the five companies.

He wanted temporary injunctions preventing changes to company registers and registration of further encumbrances.

He also sought to stop the disposal of unallotted shares and company assets.

The proposed restrictions covered machinery, land, bank accounts and interests in other companies.

More fundamentally, he wanted the court to declare the disputed transfers illegal, fraudulent and void.

He also sought orders compelling the Registrar of Companies to cancel the transfers and restore the shares.

However, Suraj and the five companies challenged the proceedings through a preliminary objection.

Their lawyers, Daly Inamdar Advocates, argued that the application was fundamentally incompetent.

They maintained that the court could not entertain substantive claims commenced through a miscellaneous civil application.

The lawyers argued that allegations requiring a full trial should have been instituted through a properly filed suit.

They described the combination of a plaint and miscellaneous application as procedurally incompatible.

No Proper Suit

Justice Ngaah agreed that Khalid’s proceedings were fundamentally defective.

The judge observed that the application raised several contested factual questions requiring proper pleadings and evidence.

He emphasised that allegations of fraud must be specifically pleaded and established through evidence.

The judge also questioned the nature of the reliefs sought through the notice of motion.

These included declarations of fraud, cancellation of share transfers and rectification of five company registers.

They also included monetary claims running back to 2013, with interest.

Justice Ngaah said such substantive remedies could not properly be pursued through the interlocutory application.

He described Khalid’s case as the antithesis of a straightforward dispute founded on uncontested allegations.

The judge stressed that each allegation required particularised pleadings, a defence and evidence tested through cross-examination.

He consequently struck out the proceedings rather than dismissing the substantive claims.

READ ALSO: Mombasa Cement Wins KSh1.65 Billion Insurance Fight With Kenindia Over Collapsed Silo

He explained that the court’s jurisdiction had not been properly invoked through a recognised legal process.

“The defect is not a technicality,” Justice Ngaah said.

He added that the problem was not an incorrect heading or procedural description.

Instead, the proceedings lacked a legally recognised foundation for determining the substantive claims.

Despite striking out the application, the judge acknowledged that the dispute genuinely deserved a trial.

The ruling does not establish whether the alleged forgery occurred or whether the disputed transfers were fraudulent.

Those questions remain unresolved and require determination through properly instituted proceedings.

PAY ATTENTION: Reach us at info@gotta.news.

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.

Most Popular

Exit mobile version